Not a Crime of Passion: Why Italy Keeps Failing Women
On September 4th, 45-year-old Lorena Isceri was killed in Florence by her ex-partner. Three days later, around 2,000 people gathered with candles on via Panciatichi. She is the seventh woman killed in Italy since mid-August.
In this episode, we open with a 1981 voice interview with a man explaining, calmly, that a wife's affair is unforgivable and a husband's isn't, recorded just as Italy abolished the delitto d'onore, the "honour killing" law that let men who killed an unfaithful wife, daughter or sister off with a fraction of the sentence for murder. From there, we ask why this keeps happening: from Artemisia Gentileschi to My Brilliant Friend, from Mussolini's idea of womanhood to the manosphere and tradwives, and why so many women can't simply "just leave."
Georgette shares the night she helped a friend escape a violent relationship at 23. Valentina talks about the financial control her own grandmother lived with, and how she's raising her son to see women as equals, not property. And we talk about what actually helps: the new femicide law, education in schools, shelters outside the big cities, and believing women the first time they speak up.
Since we recorded, Se domani non torno, a film about the murder of 22-year-old Giulia Cecchettin, has gone straight to the top of the Italian box office, something that every family in Italy should see.
This is a hard one but Thank you for listening.
Episode highlights
- A 1981 street interview on adultery, "honour" and who gets to be forgiven, and why it still sounds familiar
- Lorena Isceri, the Florence vigil, and the spike in femicides in the second half of August
- Tania Terrin, who went to the police multiple times before she was killed
- Georgette's story: helping a friend leave a violent relationship in secret, 20 years ago
- Why "it would never happen to me" misses the point: abuse is often a slow burn, and abusers have two faces
- Trauma bonding, fear, isolation and money: the "invisible chains" that keep women from leaving
- Artemisia Gentileschi, raped at 17 and tortured during the trial, and My Brilliant Friend and how normal domestic violence once seemed
- The delitto d'onore: introduced under Fascism, abolished only in 1981
- Italy's new femicide law, and why a law alone isn't enough
- Financial abuse: Valentina on her grandmother having to ask permission to buy underwear
- Porn, the manosphere and tradwives: what young people learn about relationships when no one teaches them
- Raising kids who know what a healthy relationship looks like
- Where to get help in Italy, including Casa delle Donne in Florence
November 25th is the International Day for the Elimination of Violence Against Women.
The date honors Patria, Minerva and María Teresa Mirabal, three sisters and political activists murdered in the Dominican Republic on November 25, 1960, under the Trujillo dictatorship. Latin American feminists began marking the day in 1981, and the UN General Assembly made it official in 1999.
It's also day one of the 16 Days of Activism Against Gender-Based Violence, which runs until December 10th, Human Rights Day. Around the world, buildings and monuments are lit in orange, the colour of the UN's campaign.
In Italy, the day is marked with marches, vigils and events in towns and cities across the country:
- Red shoes and red benches (scarpe rosse and panchine rosse) are the Italian symbols. Look out for them in squares, parks and shop windows.
- Non Una di Meno holds a national march, usually in Rome on the weekend before the 25th.
- In Florence, the city and local partners hold a "minute of noise" (un minuto di rumore) flash mob in Piazza della Signoria, and the University of Florence runs a programme of talks and events in the weeks around it. The "minute of noise" echoes the one held at Giulia Cecchettin's funeral, which audiences are now repeating after screenings of Se domani non torno. Also check out this event by the Artemisia foundation.
- Florence’s libraries are becoming safe havens. The city’s municipal libraries have joined I Rifugi (“The Shelters”), a national network of 459 libraries and bookstores that offer information and a first point of contact with local anti-violence services. To mark November 25th, the Leonardo da Vinci Library hosts “Libraries as Shelters” workshops for schools on the 24th and 26th, and the Oblate holds a talk on women’s economic independence on the 25th and a session on violence in teenage relationships on the 27th.
Check your own comune's website for local events. If you go, take someone with you, and tell us about it.
Since we recorded
Se domani non torno ("If I don't come back tomorrow"), directed by Paola Randi and based on Cara Giulia, the book by Giulia Cecchettin's father Gino, opened at number one in Italy, taking more than €1.4 million in its first four days. The film follows the family left behind rather than the crime, and her killer is never shown or named. Giulia's sister Elena famously refused to call him a "monster," describing him instead as a "healthy son of patriarchal society."
Resources
- 1522: National anti-violence and anti-stalking helpline. Free, 24/7, multilingual, confidential. Also available by chat.
- 112: Emergency number.
- Centri antiviolenza: local anti-violence centres across Italy (find your nearest via 1522).
- Casa delle Donne, Florence (Le Murate): free courses for women, including financial independence coaching and job advice, and a space to be heard.
- Associazione Artemisia, Florence: support for women and children experiencing violence.
- Non Una di Meno: national feminist network, resources and organising.
- The Signal for Help: a one-handed gesture (palm out, thumb tucked in, fingers folded down over it) to show you need help without saying a word.